- Follow a bitcoin alert from Nyria to its fill at Alpaca. Nyria's bot page and Alpaca's Orders page in one frame: an alert arrives, a bitcoin buy order shows up in Alpaca and fills, then the exit alert sells it.
Comparison · Checked Oct 2026
3Commas alternative: Nyria vs 3Commas
3Commas is locked to crypto exchanges. Nyria routes the same alerts to crypto, stocks, options and spreads. On a brokerage account you own.
Pick Nyria for stocks, options or spreads, or crypto spot at a brokerage you own. Pick 3Commas for crypto perps, DCA or grid bots, a backtester, or alert-set size and stops.
More tools to weigh: the alternatives lists.
Nyria
- Paper is free. Live trading from $15 a month.
- Crypto spot live on Alpaca
- Stocks, options and spreads from the same alerts
- TradingView, Discord, Telegram and webhook alerts built in
- Multi-leg option spreads up to 4 legs (verticals, iron condors)
- Connect by broker sign-in or API key. Funds stay at your broker.
3Commas
- Crypto exchanges only. No stocks and no options.
- Crypto perpetuals on live exchanges
- Pre-built DCA and grid bots, and a backtester
- No multi-leg option builder
- TradingView alerts send a fixed JSON message built around the bot's alert code
| Feature | Nyria | 3Commas |
|---|---|---|
| Crypto spot | NyriaYes | 3CommasYes |
| Crypto perpetuals Nyria currently trades them on Nyria Paper only. | NyriaNo | 3CommasYes |
| US stocks and ETFs | NyriaYes | 3CommasNo |
| Options (single-leg and spreads) | NyriaYes | 3CommasNo |
| Bots across asset classes, side by side | NyriaYes | 3CommasNo |
| TradingView webhook A 3Commas signal bot gives you a webhook URL and a fixed JSON message built around its alert code. A Nyria strategy reads plain text or JSON in your own wording. | NyriaAny format | 3CommasFixed JSON template |
| Discord native source | NyriaYes | 3CommasNo |
| Size set in the alert A 3Commas signal bot reads the order amount from the alert. Nyria sizes each entry from the bot's own settings, a dollar amount or a unit count. | NyriaNo | 3CommasYes |
| Stop loss or take profit on entry 3Commas can set a take profit and a stop loss with the entry. Nyria places market and limit orders, and exits come from your exit alerts. | NyriaNo | 3CommasYes |
| DCA / grid bots Nyria builds no strategies for you. If you want pre-built crypto bots, 3Commas is the better fit. | NyriaNo | 3CommasYes |
| Backtester Nyria doesn't run backtests. A strategy's record is priced from each alert it received. Creators can import a backtest from TradingView, NinjaTrader or MetaTrader. | NyriaNo | 3CommasYes |
| Paper trading Every 3Commas plan includes a demo account. Nyria Paper is free with no plan and no time limit. | NyriaFree, no time limit | 3CommasIncluded from $20/mo |
| Pricing As of October 2026, Starter $20, Pro $50 and Expert $140 a month billed monthly, or $15, $38 and $105 a month billed annually. Starter is spot only, so futures need Pro or above. | Nyriafrom $15 a month | 3Commas$20 to $140/mo tiered |
From 3Commas's public pages, Oct 10, 2026. Sources: pricing, home page.
Moving from 3Commas to Nyria
Replace the 3Commas JSON with the alert text you want. No template.
Step 1
Connect Alpaca for crypto
Crypto spot runs on Alpaca.
Step 2
Add an equity broker
Charles Schwab, Tradier, tastytrade or Alpaca. The same alert source can drive bots across asset classes.
Step 3
Bring your alerts
A TradingView webhook, a Discord server or Telegram chat you run, or your own bot or service.
Step 4
Run bots across asset classes side by side
BTC spot, SPY options and AAPL shares in one dashboard, on one bill.
Questions
I only trade crypto. Why switch?
If 3Commas's grid and DCA bots cover you, stay. Nyria fits if you want stocks or options next to your crypto bots.
Does Nyria have grid bots?
No. Nyria places the alerts you send it. A grid or DCA strategy lives in your Pine Script or service, and fires alerts at Nyria.
Can I use the same alert for BTC and SPY?
Yes. One alert source can drive several bots on several brokers. Set each bot's size and tickers in Nyria.
Does Nyria support futures like 3Commas?
Not live. Crypto perpetuals run on Nyria Paper only. If you trade them live, 3Commas covers them and Nyria doesn't.
More to read
Put an alert through it
Trade and test free on paper. No card required. No broker needed.