Comparison / Checked Oct 2026
Trade Ideas alternative: Nyria vs Trade Ideas
Trade Ideas is a US stock scanner that generates Holly AI signals with entry and stop levels and sends automated orders to IBKR, TradeStation, E*TRADE, Alpaca and more. Standard is $127 a month; Premium, which adds Auto Trading, is $254. Nyria routes alerts from TradingView, Discord and Telegram to Schwab, Tradier, tastytrade and Alpaca from $15 a month.
Pick Nyria if you already have a strategy in TradingView, Discord or Telegram and want to automate it at Schwab, Tradier or tastytrade. Pick Trade Ideas if you want a stock scanner that generates its own signals with entry and stop levels, plus automated trading from its alerts.
More tools to weigh: all alternatives lists.
Nyria
- Paper is free. Live trading from $15 a month.
- Routes your own TradingView, Discord or Telegram alerts
- Schwab, Tradier, tastytrade and Alpaca live
- Multi-leg options up to 4 legs
- No per-bot fees on any paid tier
- Alert-driven, not scanner-driven
Trade Ideas
- Standard $127/mo ($89/mo annual); Premium $254/mo ($178/mo annual)
- Holly AI signals with entry and stop levels, labelled TI Premium
- Money Machine automated trading at IBKR, TradeStation, E*TRADE, Alpaca and more
- Real-time stock scanner with streaming alerts
- OddsMaker backtesting, labelled TI Premium
- Simulated paper trading on every TI Pro plan
| Feature | Nyria | Trade Ideas |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing model Trade Ideas Standard at $127 a month lists real-time data, paper trading and in-app trading. Premium at $254 adds AI signals, backtesting and Auto Trading. Billed annually, they are $1,068 and $2,136 a year, or $89 and $178 a month. | Nyriafrom $15 a month, priced by total entry allocation | Trade IdeasStandard $127/mo; Premium $254/mo |
| Schwab Charles Schwab is not on Trade Ideas' brokers page. | NyriaYes | Trade IdeasNot listed |
| tastytrade tastytrade is not on Trade Ideas' brokers page. | NyriaYes | Trade IdeasNot listed |
| Tradier Tradier is not on Trade Ideas' brokers page. | NyriaYes | Trade IdeasNot listed |
| Alpaca Alpaca is on Trade Ideas' brokers page as an API integration. | NyriaYes | Trade IdeasYes |
| Interactive Brokers Interactive Brokers is on Trade Ideas' brokers page as an API integration. Nyria does not currently support IBKR. | NyriaNo | Trade IdeasYes |
| E*TRADE and TradeStation Both are on Trade Ideas' brokers page as API integrations. | NyriaNo | Trade IdeasYes |
| TradingView webhook Trade Ideas generates its own scanner and Holly AI signals. Its features page does not list TradingView webhooks as an input. | NyriaYes | Trade IdeasNot listed |
| Discord native source Not listed on Trade Ideas' site. | NyriaYes | Trade IdeasNot listed |
| Telegram native source Not listed on Trade Ideas' site. | NyriaYes | Trade IdeasNot listed |
| Stock scanner Trade Ideas runs a real-time stock scanner with streaming alerts. Nyria does not generate signals; it routes alerts the user already has. | NyriaNo | Trade IdeasYes |
| Holly AI signals Each signal carries a symbol, an entry price and a stop, per Trade Ideas' features page. | NyriaNo | Trade IdeasTI Premium |
| Automated execution Money Machine automates trading from Trade Ideas' Top Lists and Streaming Alerts. | NyriaYes | Trade IdeasMoney Machine (TI Premium) |
| Multi-leg options (spreads) Multi-leg options are not mentioned on Trade Ideas' features page, which lists Unusual Options Activity scanning. | NyriaUp to 4 legs, one expiry | Trade IdeasNot listed |
| Paper trading Trade Ideas' pricing page lists Real-Time Paper Trading on Standard. | NyriaFree, no time limit | Trade IdeasSimulated Trading, every TI Pro plan |
| Sell access to your strategy Not listed on Trade Ideas' site. | NyriaYes | Trade IdeasNot listed |
From Trade Ideas's public pages, Oct 24, 2026. Sources: pricing, features, brokers.
Moving from Trade Ideas to Nyria
Your alerts keep the wording they already have.
Step 1
Connect your broker
Schwab, Tradier, tastytrade or Alpaca connect by signing in at the broker. Alpaca uses an API key.
Step 2
Set up your alert source
Point your TradingView, Discord or Telegram alert to your Nyria webhook. The alert body can be plain text or JSON.
Step 3
Set a budget per entry
Set each bot's budget per entry. Live trading starts at $15 a month, priced by total entry allocation.
Step 4
Paper-trade first
Run the strategy on Nyria Paper at no cost, then move to a live broker when you are ready.
Questions
Does Nyria have a stock scanner like Trade Ideas?
No. Nyria routes the alerts you already have from TradingView, Discord or Telegram. Trade Ideas runs its own scanner and Holly AI signals, which include entry and stop levels. If you want a scanner that finds setups for you, Trade Ideas is built for that.
How does pricing by total entry allocation work?
Your total entry allocation is the budget per entry across all bots on your live broker accounts. It's what your live bots could put in at once if they all entered together. Two live bots at $4,000 and $6,000 per entry make $10,000, which is the $100 tier. At $6,000 each they make $12,000, which moves you to the $20,000 tier at $200 a month. Bots on a creator's Premium strategy count toward that strategy's tier instead. $20,000 of it is $200 a month, or $2,000 a year. Nothing is charged per bot, per scan or per alert.
Does Trade Ideas support Schwab or tastytrade?
Neither is on Trade Ideas' brokers page, which lists TradeStation, Interactive Brokers, E*TRADE and Alpaca as API integrations. Nyria has Schwab and tastytrade live today.
Can I sell access to my strategy on Nyria?
Yes. Set the strategy to Premium, then sell it through Nyria's checkout or map your own Whop or Stripe products to tiers. Members trade it automatically in their own brokerage accounts.
More to read
Put an alert through it
Trade and test free on paper, forever. No card or broker required.